Real EstateCommentary · fictional firm
Commercial Leases: The Clauses Tenants Overlook
Rent and term receive most of the attention in a lease negotiation. The clauses that cause disputes are usually found elsewhere.
- Published
- Reading
- 2 min read
- Practice
- Real Estate
Key points
- 1.Read reinstatement obligations before signing, not before leaving.
- 2.Understand which outgoings and service charges the tenant will bear, and how they can change.
- 3.Make sure renewal options and registration protect the tenancy as intended.
For many businesses a commercial lease is one of their largest fixed commitments. Negotiations naturally focus on rent, rent-free periods and the length of the term. In our experience, the disputes that follow are more often about provisions that received little attention at the outset.
Reinstatement
Many leases require the tenant to return the premises to their original condition at the end of the term. For a tenant that has invested in a substantial fit-out, that obligation can be expensive — sometimes a meaningful fraction of the original fit-out cost. It is worth agreeing in advance what must be removed and what may stay, and recording the condition of the premises at handover with photographs and a signed schedule.
Service charges and outgoings
The rent is rarely the whole cost of occupation. Service charges, utilities, insurance and quit rent or assessment contributions may all fall on the tenant. The lease should say which outgoings the tenant bears, how service charges are calculated, and on what basis they may be increased during the term.
Renewal options
An option to renew is only as useful as its drafting. An option to renew “at a rent to be mutually agreed” may amount to no more than an agreement to negotiate. A clear mechanism for setting the renewal rent — by reference to market rent determined by an independent valuer if the parties cannot agree, for example — gives the option real value.
“An option to renew is only as useful as its drafting.”
Registration and protection
Under the National Land Code, a lease for a term exceeding three years should be registered to take effect as a registered lease, while shorter tenancies may be exempt from registration and can be protected in other ways, such as by endorsement. A tenant that has invested heavily in premises should check how its interest is protected if the property is sold or charged during the term.
Relocation, redevelopment and assignment
Some leases allow the landlord to relocate the tenant within the building, or to terminate early for redevelopment. Others restrict the tenant’s ability to assign the lease or sublet part of the premises, which matters if the business grows, shrinks or is sold. These clauses deserve attention before signing, when they can still be negotiated.
A lease is read most closely when something goes wrong. It is far cheaper to read it closely before anything does.
General commentary written for AUREL & TAN, a fictional firm created as a design concept. It discusses the law in general terms, cites no cases and is not legal advice. Specific advice should always be taken on the facts of a particular matter from a qualified lawyer.
